Long Island's Best Restaurant [Updated 2025]

With my trusty fork in hand and a never-ending appetite for adventure, I dove into the culinary scene of Long Island, tasting my way through 12 top-notch restaurants. Each place had its own unique charm and flavor, making this quest nothing short of deliciously enlightening.

You can trust my palate because I’m not just a casual diner; I’ve spent years seeking out hidden gems and local favorites. I've savored everything from mouthwatering seafood to comforting Italian classics, and I’m ready to spill the beans on where to find the ultimate dining experience. So, if you’re ready to embark on your own gastronomic adventure, let’s dig into what makes this restaurant truly exceptional!

Manetta's Ristorante

Nestled in the heart of Long Island, Manetta's Ristorante is a culinary gem that dances between tradition and innovation. On entering, the inviting aroma of freshly cooked pasta and simmering sauces instantly captivates the senses. The authentic Italian fare was nothing short of spectacular; each dish was a symphony of flavors that made my taste buds sing! I savored their signature lasagna, layered with love and bursting with rich, savory goodness. The attentive staff added a touch of warmth, making the experience all the more delightful. For a taste of Italy right here on Long Island, Manetta's is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC for Birthday Dinner.

Lakehouse

Nestled on the serene shores of Lake Ontario, Lakehouse in Long Island is a culinary gem that delights the senses. From the moment I stepped in, the ambiance whispered elegance, perfectly complementing the incredible menu focused on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. The saffron risotto was a masterpiece, rich and creamy, while the grilled octopus danced with flavors that made my taste buds sing. With a stellar wine list and attentive service, every detail was meticulously crafted. If you seek the perfect blend of sophistication and warmth, this is where dining dreams come true. Don't miss out on this culinary oasis!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Queens for Birthday.

LOLA

Nestled in the heart of Long Island, LOLA is an absolute gem that dazzled my taste buds! The ambiance is a delightful mix of cozy charm and urban chic, making it a perfect spot for any occasion. I savored their signature lobster mac and cheese, a rich and creamy masterpiece that danced on my palate. The service was impeccable—attentive yet unobtrusive, allowing me to truly soak in the experience. With a thoughtful wine list and a variety of unique dishes, LOLA isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a celebration of flavor that keeps me dreaming of my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Brooklyn.

The Fifth Season

With a vibrant atmosphere that radiates both elegance and warmth, The Fifth Season delights at every turn. The culinary creations are a masterpiece, each dish bursting with flavors that dance on the palate. I savored the duck confit, which was cooked to perfection with a crispy skin that gave way to tender, juicy meat. And the wine selection? Simply divine! The attentive staff adds to the charm, making every visitor feel truly special. Whether it's a romantic night out or a celebration with friends, The Fifth Season is a must-visit destination that promises an unforgettable dining experience in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Brooklyn Park.

Kyma

Kyma dazzled me with its exceptional blend of Mediterranean flavors and warm ambiance. As I stepped inside, the chic decor immediately enveloped me in a vibrant atmosphere, setting the stage for a memorable meal. The seafood is the star here, particularly the grilled octopus, which was tender and bursting with flavor. Paired with a glass of crisp Greek wine, my taste buds danced with delight. The attentive staff treated me like family, enhancing the overall experience. If you're seeking a dash of exotic charm in Long Island, Kyma is a delicious gem waiting to be discovered!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC for Special Occasion.

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

Nestled by the water, Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar dazzles with its stunning views and a menu to match. From the moment I entered, the atmosphere was alive—a perfect blend of sophistication and warmth. I savored their signature filet mignon, cooked to perfection and accented by rich, buttery sauces. The exquisite seafood options left me in awe, especially the lobster tail. Don't overlook the dessert—the molten chocolate cake is a heavenly ending! With attentive service and a vibrant ambiance, it's clear why Prime stands out among Long Island's finest. This gem is truly a culinary treasure!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC During Christmas.

Tellers: An American Chophouse

Tellers: An American Chophouse is a culinary gem that shines brightly on Long Island! From the moment I stepped inside, the elegant ambiance enveloped me, promising a delightful evening. The steaks, cooked to perfection, were a carnivore’s dream, bursting with rich flavors that danced on my palate. Equally impressive were the side dishes, especially the creamy truffle mashed potatoes—an absolute must-try! The attentive staff added charm to the experience, always ensuring my glass was full. Whether it's a special occasion or just a desire for great food, Tellers is a delightful choice that consistently exceeds expectations. A true winner!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC for Birthday.

Blend on the Water

Nestled along the waterfront, Blend on the Water delivers a delightful culinary escape that tantalizes the senses. From the moment I stepped in, the stunning views of the skyline captivated me – a perfect backdrop for an exceptional meal. The fusion of flavors is remarkable, creatively blending Latin and Asian influences. I savored their renowned tacos and the signature cocktails, which were both vibrant and refreshing. The ambiance is chic yet inviting, making it ideal for any occasion. If you're seeking a delightful dining experience that dazzles both your palate and your eyes, Blend on the Water truly stands out as a top contender in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC West Side.

Seasons 52

Tucked away in its chic ambiance, Seasons 52 offers a delightful culinary journey that celebrates seasonal ingredients. Each dish is a work of art, beautifully plated to tantalize both your taste buds and eyes. I savored the grilled mahi-mahi—its freshness was palpable, paired perfectly with vibrant seasonal veggies. The mini desserts? A playful touch that lets you indulge without overdoing it; I loved the key lime pie! Add in their extensive wine list, and you have an experience that’s simply unforgettable. For a dining adventure that embodies freshness and flavor, Seasons 52 is a must-visit gem on Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC at Christmas.

Blackstone Steakhouse

During my recent visit to Blackstone Steakhouse, I was greeted by an atmosphere that perfectly blends elegance and comfort. The sizzling steaks stole the show—cooked to perfection, each bite was a juicy explosion of flavor. The wine selection was robust, complementing my meal beautifully. The attentive staff added to the charm, making me feel like a valued guest rather than just another diner. For dessert, the _ molten chocolate cake_ was a decadent finale that danced on my palate. Overall, Blackstone truly epitomizes a premier steakhouse experience, making it a top contender in Long Island's culinary scene.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in NYC for Teens.

The Capital Grille

Dining at The Capital Grille in Long Island was a culinary delight. From the moment I stepped in, I was enveloped in an atmosphere of sophistication and warmth. The dry-aged steaks are simply divine, cooked to perfection, while the wine selection is both impressive and extensive. The service was impeccable, with staff eager to share their knowledge about each dish. Don’t skip the lobster mac & cheese; it's a game-changer! If you’re looking for an experience that marries luxury with comfort, this is the place to be. The Capital Grille truly sets the bar high for fine dining on Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Brooklyn for Birthday Dinner.

Maiella

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Long Island, Maiella is a culinary gem that left me delighted and satisfied. The moment you step in, you're greeted by an atmosphere that beautifully blends elegance with warmth. The menu showcases seasonal Italian dishes, each plate a work of art bursting with flavor. I savored the handmade pasta—every bite was a revelation! The staff exudes genuine hospitality, ensuring you feel pampered throughout your meal. To top it off, their wine selection is impressive and perfectly complements the dishes. For an unforgettable dining experience, Maiella is truly a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Manhattan Cheap.