NYC's Best Pub [Updated 2024]

I have scoured the city, visiting a staggering 12 pubs and carefully assessing each one for its ambiance, drink selection, and overall experience. Prepare to be taken on a journey through the heart of New York City's pub scene, as I reveal the hidden gems and tried-and-true favorites that will quench your thirst and satisfy your cravings.

From cozy neighborhood haunts to trendy hotspots, I've left no stone unturned in my quest for the perfect pint. So sit back, grab a cold one, and let me be your trusted companion as we explore the finest establishments that NYC has to offer.

Peter Dillon's Pub

Highlights
Friendly staff
Cheapest drinks
Free pool
Lovely atmosphere
Great tequila and beer selection
Found lost credit card

First and foremost, let me start by saying that Peter Dillon's Pub is hands down one of the best pubs I've visited in NYC. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendliest staff I've ever encountered. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and made me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the drinks. Peter Dillon's Pub boasts the cheapest drinks I've found in the city. I couldn't believe how reasonable the prices were, especially considering the prime location. And don't even get me started on the selection! With a wide array of tequilas and beers to choose from, I was in beverage heaven.

One of the highlights of my visit was the free pool. Yes, you read that right. They have a pool table, completely free to play. It was a perfect way to relax and enjoy some friendly competition with my friends.

The atmosphere at Peter Dillon's Pub is simply lovely. It has that classic pub charm, with a cozy interior and a warm ambiance. It's the kind of place where you instantly feel like a regular, even if it's your first visit.

Lastly, I must commend the staff for going above and beyond. A fellow patron lost their credit card, and the attentive staff found and returned it promptly. It's this kind of care and attention to detail that sets Peter Dillon's Pub apart from the rest.

In conclusion, if you're looking for the best pub in NYC, look no further than Peter Dillon's Pub. With its friendly staff, cheap drinks, free pool, and overall delightful atmosphere, it's a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable pub experience.

You might also want to check out the best computer science schools in NYC.

McGee's Pub

Highlights
Great Irish Pub
"How I Met Your Mother" references
Delicious food
Good drinks
Nice bar area

Upon entering McGee's Pub, I was immediately struck by the cozy and authentic atmosphere. It truly embodies the essence of a great Irish pub. The walls were adorned with charming memorabilia and the staff welcomed me with warm smiles.

Being a fan of the hit TV show "How I Met Your Mother," I instantly recognized the references to the show that are peppered throughout the pub. From the yellow umbrella hanging in a corner to the playful nods on the menu, the show's fans will feel right at home.

Moving onto the main course, the food at McGee's Pub did not disappoint. The menu boasts a wide range of Irish classics, from fish and chips to shepherd's pie, all cooked to perfection. The combination of warm, hearty flavors and generous portions left me fully satisfied.

With regards to drinks, the bar did not disappoint either. The selection was varied, catering to all preferences. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Guinness or a creative cocktail, the skilled bartenders know their craft.

One of the highlights of McGee's Pub is the well-designed bar area. It offers ample seating and a lively atmosphere. Whether you're looking to unwind after a long day or gather with friends for a night out, this pub provides the perfect setting.

Overall, McGee's Pub is a delightful establishment that captures the spirit of an Irish pub with its friendly ambiance, delicious food, and selection of beverages. Whether you're a "How I Met Your Mother" fan or simply looking for a great pub experience in NYC, McGee's Pub is definitely worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Pig n Whistle

Highlights
Festive Decor
Delicious Food
Friendly Staff
Variety of Options
Reasonable Prices

Walking into Pig n Whistle, I was immediately drawn in by the festive decor. The walls were adorned with old-fashioned memorabilia, giving the place a cozy and nostalgic atmosphere. The dim lighting and wooden furniture added to the pub's charm.

But it wasn't just the ambiance that impressed me. The menu at Pig n Whistle offered a variety of options that catered to all tastes. From classic pub fare like burgers and fish and chips to more adventurous dishes like Irish lamb stew, there was something for everyone. And let me tell you, the food was absolutely delicious! Each bite was bursting with flavor, leaving me wanting more.

What truly made my experience memorable, though, was the friendly staff. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and always ready with a smile. They made me feel welcome from the moment I stepped through the door, and their recommendations were spot-on.

One thing that I particularly appreciated about Pig n Whistle was the reasonable prices. Despite its prime location in NYC, the pub didn't break the bank. I could enjoy a great meal and drinks without emptying my wallet.

Overall, my visit to Pig n Whistle exceeded my expectations. The festive decor, delicious food, and friendly staff all contributed to making it a top contender for the title of the best pub in NYC. If you're looking for a place with a great atmosphere, tasty food, and reasonable prices, this is definitely a pub you shouldn't miss.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Judge Roy Bean Public House

Alrighty then, let me take you on a wild ride through my visit to Judge Roy Bean Public House in NYC. This place exudes a playful and lively vibe, perfect for a pub crawl adventure. The selection of craft beers and whiskies will make any connoisseur weak in the knees. And their food? Let's just say my taste buds were doing the happy dance. If you're looking for a whimsical and top-notch pub experience, this is the place to be. Yeehaw!

You might also want to check out the best realtors in Manhattan Beach CA.

The Grafton

The Grafton in NYC is a delightful hidden gem that offers a playful twist on traditional pub fare. The atmosphere is charming, with cozy seating and warm lighting. The beer selection is impressive, featuring both local craft brews and international favorites. Don't miss the signature cocktails that pack a flavorful punch. Cheers to finding the best pub in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

The Long Hall Pub & Grocery

The Long Hall Pub & Grocery in NYC is the epitome of a cozy yet vibrant pub. With its Irish flair, friendly staff, and delicious selection of beers and whiskies, this place exudes charm. Whether you're looking for a quiet drink or a lively night out, The Long Hall is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy the authentic pub atmosphere.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

11th St. Bar

Let me start by saying that 11th St. Bar sets the bar high for pubs in NYC. This hidden gem combines a relaxed atmosphere with an impressive selection of craft beers and spirits. The live music adds a lively touch, making it the perfect spot to unwind with friends after a long day. Trust me, this place is a winner.

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Malachy's Irish Pub

Malachy's Irish Pub in NYC is a pub that is definitely worth a visit. With its lively atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious selection of drinks, it has all the ingredients for a great night out. The cozy interior and authentic Irish charm create the perfect setting for enjoying a pint of Guinness or indulging in some traditional Irish grub. So, if you're on the hunt for the best pub in NYC, give Malachy's a try!

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

McCarthy's Pub NYC

McCarthy's Pub NYC is a delightful spot that exudes a welcoming atmosphere from the moment you step in. The cozy wooden interior transports you to an Irish oasis in the heart of NYC. The selection of perfectly poured pints and lip-smacking pub grub will make both locals and tourists crave for more. Don't miss out on their incredible live music nights that will have you tapping your feet in no time. McCarthy's Pub NYC truly deserves a spot among the city's best pubs.

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

Connolly's

I can confidently say that Connolly's is a top contender for the title of best pub in NYC. With its cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and an impressive selection of drinks, it's a haven for pub enthusiasts. Whether you're looking for a lively night out or a relaxed evening with friends, Connolly's has got you covered. The old-fashioned charm of the place adds to its appeal, making it a must-visit spot in the city. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

Peculier Pub

Picture this: a peculiar gem nestled on Bleecker Street. Peculier Pub is where the beer flows like a whimsical river, and the atmosphere is as inviting as a warm embrace. With an extensive selection of brews, this pub is an absolute delight for any beer aficionado. Cheers to this eccentric wonder of NYC!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.

McSorley’s Old Ale House

McSorley's Old Ale House in NYC is an iconic pub that combines playful vibes with a professional atmosphere. Sipping their signature ale, watching the sawdust-covered floor, and chatting with the friendly staff made me feel like a part of history. It's a must-visit spot for beer enthusiasts looking for a taste of old New York.