NYC's Best Pina Colada [Updated 2024]

With my extensive knowledge and love for this tropical concoction, I have had the pleasure of sampling pina coladas from all corners of the concrete jungle. Throughout my journey, I meticulously reviewed twelve establishments in search of the perfect blend of creamy coconut, sweet pineapple, and a hint of rum.

Each location was evaluated based on the quality of ingredients, blending technique, and overall taste experience. So, if you're a pina colada enthusiast like me, stay tuned as I unveil the hidden gems that will transport your taste buds to a sun-soaked beach in paradise.

Get ready to sip and savor your way through the best pina coladas that NYC has to offer!

Otto's Shrunken Head

Highlights
Hidden gem
Bold concoctions
Offbeat vibe
Great music
Tasty cocktails

Nestled in the bustling streets of NYC, Otto's Shrunken Head is truly a hidden gem when it comes to finding the best pina colada in town. This funky tiki bar, with its offbeat vibe and eclectic decor, sets the stage for a memorable cocktail experience.

As I stepped inside, I was immediately captivated by the lively atmosphere. The walls adorned with tiki masks, vintage surfboards, and colorful string lights transported me to a tropical paradise, and I knew I was in for a treat.

The bartenders at Otto's Shrunken Head are true mixologists, passionately crafting bold concoctions. And boy, did their pina colada impress me! Made with a perfect blend of fresh pineapple juice, creamy coconut cream, and a hint of rum, it was a tropical delight that instantly transported me to a sunny beach.

But it wasn't just the pina colada that stole the show. The music, a mix of 60s surf rock and alternative tunes, created an infectious energy that had everyone tapping their feet. It was evident that Otto's Shrunken Head isn't just about the cocktails; it's about the entire experience.

In addition to the marvelous pina coladas, the extensive cocktail menu offered a myriad of delightful options, each one more tempting than the last. It was evident that the team at Otto's Shrunken Head takes great pride in their craft and ensures that every cocktail is perfectly balanced and bursting with flavor.

If you're in the mood for a pina colada that will transport you to a tropical paradise while treating your taste buds to a tantalizing experience, make your way to Otto's Shrunken Head. This playful yet professional tiki bar is a destination worth discovering. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in NYC.

Pineapple Club

Highlights
Lovely atmosphere
Pineapple hospitality
Unique cocktails
Charming decor
Attentive and accommodating service

As soon as I entered Pineapple Club, I was immediately captivated by the lovely atmosphere. The vibrant tropical vibes and the tantalizing scent of freshly cut pineapples transported me to a beachside paradise, right in the heart of NYC.

The moment I took a seat at the bar, the pineapple hospitality enveloped me. The bartenders greeted me with warm smiles and made me feel like a valued guest. Their passion for mixology was evident as they created unique cocktails with precision and flair.

Not only were the pina coladas at Pineapple Club exceptional, they were truly a work of art. Served in pineapples with a colorful umbrella perched on top, each sip was a delightful combination of creamy coconut and tangy pineapple flavors.

The charming decor added to the overall experience, with tropical murals and cozy seating that invited me to relax and savor my drink. I couldn't help but snap a few pictures to capture the ambiance of this hidden gem.

What truly set Pineapple Club apart was their attentive and accommodating service. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that I had the perfect pina colada experience. They listened to my preferences and even made a personalized variation of the classic cocktail.

In conclusion, Pineapple Club is a must-visit spot for pina colada enthusiasts in NYC. With its lovely atmosphere, pineapple hospitality, unique cocktails, charming decor, and attentive service, it embodies the perfect blend of tropical vacation vibes and metropolitan elegance. Cheers to finding the best pina colada in the city!

You might also want to check out the best breweries in NYC.

Tiki Chick

Highlights
Fun Tiki bar
Strong cocktails
$5 sandwich deal
Delicious food
Amazing drinks

As soon as I stepped into Tiki Chick, I knew I was in for a tropical treat. The atmosphere was lively and fun, with Tiki-themed decor and a friendly bartender ready to whip up some tantalizing cocktails.

I quickly ordered their signature pina colada, and boy, was I in for a surprise. The drink hit me with a burst of fruity flavors that transported me to a beachside paradise. The combination of fresh pineapple, creamy coconut, and a splash of rum was absolutely divine. This strong concoction had just the right balance of sweetness and tanginess. It was the perfect pick-me-up after a long day.

But Tiki Chick had more to offer than just amazing drinks. I couldn't resist trying their $5 sandwich deal, and let me tell you - it was a steal. The sandwich was generously filled with tender, flavorful meat and fresh veggies. It was the ideal accompaniment to my pina colada, enhancing the overall experience.

Though my focus was on finding the best pina colada in NYC, I couldn't help but explore the menu further. To my delight, the food at Tiki Chick was absolutely delicious. From the flavorful wings to the mouthwatering sliders, each bite was a burst of flavor that left me craving for more.

All in all, Tiki Chick effortlessly impressed me with their delicious pina colada, vibrant atmosphere, and scrumptious food. If you're a fan of tropical vibes and amazing drinks, make sure to swing by Tiki Chick. It's a true hidden gem in NYC's thriving cocktail scene.

You might also want to check out the best clubs in Brooklyn.

Margarita Island

Hold on to your cocktail umbrellas, because Margarita Island is a tropical oasis in the midst of the concrete jungle. Their pina colada is an explosion of flavors, with a perfect balance of creamy coconut and tangy pineapple. Sip by sip, it transports you to a beachside paradise. Trust me, you'll want to get stranded on Margarita Island.

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Brooklyn.

Tommy Bahama Restaurant, Bar & Store

Tommy Bahama Restaurant, Bar & Store in NYC is an island oasis where the pina coladas take you on a tropical journey. Creamy and refreshing, their version is the perfect blend of rum, coconut, and pineapple. Sipping on this heavenly concoction transported me straight to a hammock by the beach. A must-try for any pina colada enthusiast in the Big Apple!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Harlem.

Sel Rrose

Sel Rrose in NYC proved to be a delightful surprise on my pina colada quest. The vibrant yet cozy atmosphere sets the stage for their creamy concoction. The taste of freshly squeezed pineapple, smooth coconut cream, and a hint of rum had me sipping with pleasure. Sel Rrose easily earns a spot on the list of the best pina coladas in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Brooklyn.

Sweet & Vicious

I must say, Sweet & Vicious definitely lives up to its name when it comes to their pina coladas! Deliciously sweet and infectiously vicious, each sip is a tropical explosion of smooth rum and creamy coconut. The perfect escape from the city hustle. Cheers to that!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Brooklyn.

Broken Land

Let me start by saying, wow, what a fantastic pina colada! The moment the creamy concoction touched my lips, I was transported to a tropical paradise. The balance of sweet pineapple and smooth coconut was simply divine. The presentation was also top-notch, with a beautifully garnished glass and a cute little umbrella. The atmosphere at Broken Land was cozy and laid-back, the perfect spot to sip on this tropical delight. Overall, Broken Land has definitely made it onto my list of the best pina coladas in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Long Island City.

Las' Lap

Las' Lap in NYC is a playful paradise that serves up one phenomenal pina colada. The blend of creamy coconut, luscious pineapple, and a hint of rum creates a tantalizing treat that transports you to a tropical getaway. A must-try for any pina colada enthusiast!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Manhattan.

Surf Bar

Surf Bar in NYC is an exhilarating beach-themed oasis in the heart of the concrete jungle. Their pina colada is like a tropical vacation in a glass, with creamy coconut and luscious pineapple flavors that instantly transport you to a sandy beach. It's the ultimate summer indulgence and a must-try for any piña colada enthusiast in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Brooklyn Heights.

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe

Get ready to shake your taste buds! Miss Lily's 7A Cafe in NYC is a tropical paradise in the heart of the city. Their pina colada is a creamy concoction of fresh pineapple, coconut, and a touch of rum that tastes like a Caribbean vacation in a glass. Don't miss out on this delicious escape!

Zombie Hut

Zombie Hut in NYC, oh what a tropical delight! Sipping their pina colada felt like a mini getaway to the Caribbean. The smooth blend of rum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice was simply paradise in a glass. This hidden gem deserves a spot on the list of best pina coladas in NYC.