The Absolute Best Bars in Brooklyn Heights [Updated 2024]

Step into the vibrant world of Brooklyn Heights, where the bar scene is a delightful blend of classic charm and trendy hotspots. After exploring and reviewing a whopping 12 bars, I am ready to unveil the absolute cream of the crop.

From cozy neighborhood gems to stylish cocktail lounges, this guide has it all. Whether you're a seasoned local or a curious visitor, get ready to embark on a boozy adventure through Brooklyn Heights as we uncover the hidden gems and spirited hangouts that will keep you coming back for more.

So grab your glass, take a sip, and let's dive into the best bars this neighborhood has to offer!

Custom House

Highlights
Nicest people
Consistent food
Great drink selection

Custom House, located in the charming neighborhood of Brooklyn Heights, stood out to me as one of the best bars in the area. From the moment I walked in, the warm and welcoming atmosphere immediately made me feel like a regular.

One highlight that sets Custom House apart is their staff. The people who work here are some of the nicest individuals I've ever come across in a bar. They are knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely passionate about providing excellent service. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular, expect to be treated like a valued guest.

Another aspect that impressed me about Custom House is their commitment to consistency in their food. Each dish I had was prepared with care and attention to detail. From the perfectly cooked steaks to the flavorsome vegetarian options, every menu item delivered on taste and presentation.

Of course, a great bar wouldn't be complete without an impressive drink selection, and Custom House definitely delivers in that department. Their extensive menu features a wide range of craft beers, creative cocktails, and a well-curated wine list. I highly recommend trying their signature house cocktails - they are expertly crafted and bursting with flavor.

In conclusion, Custom House in Brooklyn Heights is a gem among bars. With its friendly staff, consistent quality of food, and a fantastic drink selection, it's no wonder this establishment has garnered such a positive reputation. Whether you're looking for a casual night out or a special occasion, Custom House is a surefire choice for an unforgettable experience in Brooklyn Heights.

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in NYC.

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill

Highlights
Nice atmosphere
Great for gathering
Comedy show every Wednesday
Selective menu
Friendly and welcoming staff

From the moment I stepped into O'Keefe's Bar & Grill, I knew I was in for a fantastic night. The atmosphere was cozy yet vibrant, with dimmed lighting and a tastefully arranged interior. The bar was bustling with activity, but not overwhelming. It was the perfect balance between lively and relaxed.

O'Keefe's is the ideal spot for gathering with friends or colleagues. Whether you're catching up with old pals or looking to unwind after a long day at work, this place has got you covered. The friendly staff made sure we felt right at home, providing excellent service with a smile.

One of the standout features of O'Keefe's is their comedic talent. Every Wednesday, they host a hysterical comedy show that had the entire place in stitches. It was the perfect mid-week treat, and I couldn't stop laughing throughout the entire performance.

When it comes to their menu, O'Keefe's takes pride in their selective yet delicious offerings. From juicy burgers to flavorful vegetarian options, there's something for everyone. I highly recommend trying their signature cocktail, it was absolutely top-notch.

Overall, O'Keefe's Bar & Grill is a gem in Brooklyn Heights. The nice atmosphere, great for gathering, exceptional comedy show, selective menu, and friendly staff all contribute to the fantastic experience. I'll definitely be returning for more good times at O'Keefe's.

You might also want to check out the best clubs in Brooklyn.

Floyd, NY

Highlights
Free Bocce
Great Beers
Loads of Space
Lovely Staff
Reasonable Prices

Walking into Floyd, NY in Brooklyn Heights, I was immediately struck by the free Bocce court situated in the spacious interior. It's not often you find a bar that offers such fun and unique entertainment.

As I made my way to the bar, the impressive selection of great beers caught my eye. They offer a wide variety of craft brews that are sure to satisfy any beer lover's palate. I couldn't resist trying a flight of their local favorites.

One thing that sets Floyd, NY apart from other bars in Brooklyn Heights is the loads of space they provide. Whether you are looking to catch up with friends or enjoy a date night, this bar has plenty of seating options and room to socialize.

The lovely staff made my visit even more enjoyable. They were attentive, friendly, and quick to recommend their personal favorites from the menu. Their knowledge and enthusiasm added to the overall experience of being at Floyd, NY.

Lastly, I was pleasantly surprised by the reasonable prices at Floyd, NY. Considering its prime location in Brooklyn Heights, it was refreshing to find a bar that doesn't break the bank. You can enjoy quality drinks without compromising your budget.

Overall, my visit to Floyd, NY was a delightful experience. With its free Bocce, impressive beer selection, ample space, friendly staff, and reasonable prices, it's no wonder this bar stands out in Brooklyn Heights. I highly recommend stopping by for a night of relaxed fun and enjoyable drinks.

You might also want to check out the best breweries in NYC.

Bohemien Bar

Bohemien Bar in Brooklyn Heights is a whimsical and charming hidden gem. With its eclectic decor and cozy atmosphere, it's a delightful spot for a night out. The craft cocktails are nothing short of artistry, with unique flavors and creative presentations. The friendly staff adds to the overall welcoming vibe. If you're looking for a bar that's bohemian and fun, Bohemien Bar is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Brooklyn.

Henry Public

Henry Public in Brooklyn Heights is a charming little gem that combines nostalgia with a modern twist. Their creative cocktails will make your taste buds dance with delight while the cozy atmosphere invites you to stay and unwind. Don't miss their signature burger, it's simply divine. Cheers in style at Henry Public!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Harlem.

Vineapple

I have to say, Vineapple in Brooklyn Heights is a hidden gem for bar enthusiasts. The cozy yet trendy ambiance instantly took me in. The selection of craft cocktails was impressive, with unique flavors that left me wanting more. The friendly and knowledgeable staff added to the overall delightful experience. Vineapple is definitely a must-visit spot in Brooklyn Heights!

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Brooklyn.

Le Boudoir

Le Boudoir in Brooklyn Heights is a hidden gem that took me on a whimsical journey back in time. With its lavish decor and intimate ambiance, this charming bar offers a delightful array of artisanal cocktails that will stun even the most discerning connoisseur. Unleash your inner Marie Antoinette and indulge in the opulent experience that is Le Boudoir.

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Brooklyn.

Henry's End

Henry's End in Brooklyn Heights is a delightful destination for those seeking a bar with a playful yet professional ambiance. Their extensive selection of craft beers and expertly crafted cocktails will transport your taste buds to a whole new level of delight. Don't forget to try their mouthwatering bar bites, perfectly paired with your beverage of choice. Pro tip: make a reservation as this place fills up quickly!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Long Island City.

Chez Moi

I must say, Chez Moi in Brooklyn Heights is a delightful spot that truly lives up to its French name. From the moment you step inside, you'll be transported to a charming Parisian bistro. The intimate ambiance, complete with soft lighting and vintage decor, creates the perfect atmosphere for unwinding after a long day. The drink menu is diverse and offers a wide selection of carefully crafted cocktails and a notable wine list to satisfy even the most discerning palate. The bartenders are skilled and friendly, making you feel right at home as they expertly mix your drink. And let's not forget the delicious food! The small plates and tapas style menu pairs perfectly with their creative libations. Whether you're craving a classic French cocktail or looking to explore a new creation, Chez Moi has you covered. So if you find yourself strolling through Brooklyn Heights, be sure to make a pitstop at Chez Moi for a taste of Paris in the heart of New York City.

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Manhattan.

Boutros

I must say, Boutros is a hidden gem in Brooklyn Heights! With its intimate atmosphere, friendly staff, and an impressive selection of craft cocktails, I was instantly charmed. Their unique twists on classic drinks, like the smoky Old Fashioned, kept me coming back for more. Cheers to Boutros!

You might also want to check out the best jazz clubs in Manhattan.

Lobby Lounge

I must admit, Lobby Lounge is quite the hidden gem in Brooklyn Heights. With its laid-back yet chic atmosphere and impeccable cocktail menu, this bar knows how to elevate your night out. The blend of innovative mixology and friendly bartenders make for a truly memorable experience. Trust me, you won't want to miss out on Lobby Lounge.

The Binc

The Binc in Brooklyn Heights is a hidden gem of a bar, with its quaint yet inviting atmosphere. The craft cocktails are expertly crafted and the bar staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Whether you're looking for a quiet date spot or a lively evening with friends, The Binc is a must-visit destination.