NYC's Best Martini [Updated 2024]

Having personally reviewed a whopping 12 martinis across the city, I can confidently say that this list is the cream of the crop. From the classic establishments to the trendy speakeasies, I have left no stone unturned in my search for the perfect martini.

Whether you prefer it shaken or stirred, dry or dirty, this guide has got you covered. Join me as I take you on a journey through the glamorous world of New York City's martini scene.

Get ready to sip on liquid bliss, because after all, in the city that never sleeps, one thing is for certain - the martinis are always top-notch.

Madeline's Martini

Highlights
Speakeasy vibes
Amazing martinis
Really good food
Great vibe
Friendly service

Walking into Madeline's Martini feels like stepping back in time to the era of hidden speakeasies. The dimly lit space exudes speakeasy vibes with its cozy booths, vintage décor, and smooth jazz playing softly in the background.

But it wasn't just the atmosphere that impressed me; the martinis at Madeline's are truly amazing. The bartender's craftsmanship is evident in every sip, as they skillfully mix up classic recipes like the Dirty Martini or create innovative concoctions that tantalize the taste buds, such as the Lavender Lemon Drop with its delicate floral notes.

To accompany their stellar drink selection, Madeline's also offers a menu of really good food that perfectly complements the martinis. From their delectable charcuterie boards to their mouthwatering sliders, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail.

The overall vibe at Madeline's Martini is enticing and captivating. Patrons are friendly and engaging, creating an atmosphere that encourages conversation and connection. Whether you're chatting with the knowledgeable bartenders or striking up a conversation with fellow martini enthusiasts, you're sure to feel right at home.

Adding to the charm of Madeline's is their friendly service. The staff is attentive, providing recommendations based on personal preferences and ensuring that every guest has a memorable experience.

After my visit to Madeline's Martini, I can confidently say that it deserves a spot on the list of best martinis in NYC. So if you're in the mood to step back in time, indulge in amazing martinis, enjoy some delicious food, and soak in the friendly ambiance, Madeline's Martini should be on your must-visit list. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best martini in Manhattan.

Martiny’s

Highlights
Unique, high-end cocktails
Attentive, friendly staff
Cozy, intimate atmosphere
Outstanding service
Excellently executed drinks

Walking into Martiny’s, I was immediately drawn in by the cozy and intimate atmosphere. The dimly lit space, adorned with elegant furnishings, created the perfect ambiance for a sophisticated martini experience.

The unique, high-end cocktails on the menu caught my attention. From classic variations like the Dirty Martini to innovative concoctions like the Lavender Lemon Martini, Martiny’s offered a range of options to satisfy any discerning palate.

But what truly set Martiny’s apart was their attentive, friendly staff. From the moment I arrived, I was greeted with warmth and professionalism. The bartender took the time to guide me through their impressive selection, suggesting the perfect martini based on my preferences. Their knowledge and passion for mixology were evident in every perfectly crafted drink.

And the outstanding service did not stop at the bar. The waitstaff was attentive and made sure I had everything I needed to fully enjoy my martini experience. It was clear that Martiny’s takes pride in providing top-notch service to its patrons.

But let's not forget the excellently executed drinks. Each martini I tried was a true masterpiece. The balance of flavors and the precision in execution made every sip a delight. Whether you prefer a classic martini or a unique twist, Martiny’s delivers.

Overall, my visit to Martiny’s was a delightful adventure in the world of martinis. The combination of the cozy atmosphere, attentive staff, and excellently executed drinks make it a top contender for the title of the best martini in NYC. So if you're searching for a martini experience that is truly exceptional, Martiny’s is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best tiki bars in NYC.

Bemelmans Bar

Highlights
Cool experience
Delicately made drinks
Classy atmosphere
Amazing cocktails
Classy but unpretentious service

Walking into Bemelmans Bar, I couldn't help but feel like I was stepping into another era. The dim lighting, the live piano music softly playing in the background, and the intimate atmosphere all combined to create a cool experience that made me feel like a character in a classic Hollywood film.

The bar staff at Bemelmans Bar takes their craft seriously, and it shows in the delicately made drinks they serve. The martinis are a work of art, with each ingredient carefully measured and perfectly balanced. Sipping on my martini, I could taste the expertise and passion that went into its creation.

The atmosphere at Bemelmans Bar is undeniably classy. The polished wood bar, plush leather seats, and elegant murals on the walls create a timeless ambiance. It's the kind of place where you can imagine the likes of Frank Sinatra and Marilyn Monroe relaxing after a long day.

Speaking of cocktails, Bemelmans Bar offers a wide range of amazing cocktails beyond just martinis. From classic Old Fashioneds to inventive creations, there's something to satisfy every palate. I couldn't resist trying a few different cocktails, and each one impressed me with its unique flavors and presentation.

What truly sets Bemelmans Bar apart, however, is the service. The staff manages to strike a perfect balance between being classy but unpretentious. They're knowledgeable about their craft and can recommend the perfect cocktail for your tastes, all while making you feel welcome and comfortable.

If you're looking for a memorable martini experience in NYC, Bemelmans Bar is a must-visit. Its cool experience, delicately made drinks, classy atmosphere, amazing cocktails, and classy but unpretentious service make it a top contender for the best martini in the city.

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Brooklyn.

Temple Bar

Temple Bar in NYC was a tantalizing playground for my taste buds. Their martini was a perfect blend of bold and smooth flavors. The presentation was on point, with an artistic garnish. The bartenders were friendly and knowledgeable, adding to the memorable experience. Temple Bar definitely deserves a spot on the best martini list.

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in NYC.

The Raines Law Room at The William

Alright, so I stopped by The Raines Law Room at The William in NYC, on a mission to find the best martini in the city. And boy, was I blown away! The ambiance was sophisticated and charming, perfect for a martini connoisseur like me. The attention to detail in their cocktails was astounding, and the martinis, oh my, they were something else. Smooth, crisp, and perfectly balanced, every sip was a flavor explosion. This place definitely deserves a spot on my list of the best martinis in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Brooklyn.

B Lounge NYC

B Lounge NYC in NYC is the perfect spot for martini aficionados. Their flawlessly crafted cocktails are a game-changer, leaving me speechless with each sip. The sleek ambiance and top-notch service only added to the already unforgettable experience. Don't miss out on their martini masterpiece!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Queens.

Angel’s Share

I must say, Angel’s Share is a hidden gem tucked away behind an unmarked door inside a bustling Japanese restaurant. 🚪 The martini here is a magical elixir, with a perfect balance of smoothness and bold flavors. The bartenders at Angel’s Share are true masters of mixology, crafting each drink with a level of precision and artistry that is truly impressive. 🍸 Sipping on their martini is like taking a journey through the clouds, where every sip transports you to a place of pure bliss. The attention to detail, from the perfectly chilled glass to the garnish that dances atop the translucent liquid, is nothing short of extraordinary. 🌟 Angel’s Share has truly earned its reputation as a destination for martinis in NYC. If you're looking for a divine martini experience, make sure to visit Angel’s Share. 🍸✨

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in NYC.

Lobby Bar at The Hotel Chelsea

I have to say, the martinis at Lobby Bar at The Hotel Chelsea in NYC are the epitome of martini perfection. The ambiance is sophisticated and the bartenders are true artists behind the bar. Each sip of their martinis is a symphony of flavors, leaving you wanting more. I can confidently declare it as one of the top contenders for the best martini in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best breweries in NYC.

Verlaine

Verlaine, a popular establishment in NYC, boasts an amazing martini! Sophisticated and exquisite, their martini is a triumph of balance and flavor. With each sip, the smoothness caresses your palate, leaving you wanting more. It's no wonder why Verlaine is a contender for the best martini in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best clubs in Brooklyn.

The Bar at Baccarat Hotel

Let me tell you, stepping into The Bar at Baccarat Hotel is like entering a sparkling dreamland where elegance and opulence collide. Their martini? Sublime. Served icy cold, each sip is a symphony of flavors that dance on your palate. Pure martini perfection.

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Brooklyn.

Dante NYC

Dante NYC is an absolute gem when it comes to martinis in NYC. The intoxicating aroma of their expertly crafted cocktails will have you weak at the knees. From their classic Gibsons to their innovative twists, Dante serves up perfection in each glass. Don't wait, run to this martini paradise!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Harlem.

Ayza Wine & Chocolate Bar

Ayza Wine & Chocolate Bar in NYC, the hidden gem, sweetens the martini game. Their martinis are a delightful medley of creativity and flavor. Sipping on their chocolate-infused concoctions, I couldn't help but feel like a sophisticated chocolate sommelier. This place is definitely worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Brooklyn.