Long Island's Best Lakes [Updated 2025]

As I explored the winding paths and tranquil shores of Long Island, I was amazed by the stunning lakes tucked away in every corner. After countless weekends of paddling, picnicking, and simply soaking in the scenery, I've handpicked 12 standout locations that truly capture the island's natural beauty.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve tasted the local flavors, chatted with fellow lake enthusiasts, and immersed myself in the vibrant outdoor culture. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful escape or an adventure-filled day, these lakes have something special to offer. Let’s dive into the best spots where you can unwind, connect with nature, and create unforgettable memories!

Belmont Lake

During my delightful visit to Belmont Lake, I was immediately enchanted by its serene atmosphere and sparkling waters. Nestled within the lush expanses of Belmont Lake State Park, this idyllic spot offers a perfect blend of recreation and relaxation. I admired the picturesque walking trails that meander around the lake, ideal for leisurely strolls or energizing jogs. The calm surface reflected the vibrant hues of nature, creating a stunning backdrop for picnics or casual fishing. Whether you're seeking adventure or tranquility, Belmont Lake embodies the essence of Long Island's natural charm, making it a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best places to read in NYC.

Roslyn Pond

Nestled amidst quaint surroundings, Roslyn Pond is a hidden gem that effortlessly captivates the heart. The serene waters, framed by lush greenery, create a picturesque scene that feels like a page from a storybook. I adored the gentle ripples reflecting the sunset, turning the pond into a canvas of oranges and pinks. Perfect for leisurely strolls, this spot also invites you to enjoy a picnic on its banks. Whether you're kayaking or simply savoring the tranquility, each moment at Roslyn Pond is a delightful escape into nature. Don't miss this slice of paradise on your Long Island adventure!

You might also want to check out the best places to read in Manhattan.

Prospect Park Lake

Nestled within the vibrant Prospect Park, Prospect Park Lake is a serene gem that captivates the senses. The gentle ripple of the water reflects the canopy of lush trees, creating a picturesque escape from city life. I particularly enjoyed wandering along the scenic paths, where the vibrant sounds of nature blend with the laughter of families picnicking nearby. The lake offers not just stunning views but also recreational activities, such as paddle boating and birdwatching, enriching the visit. For anyone seeking a tranquil yet lively spot, Prospect Park Lake stands out as a must-visit destination on Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best places to read in Brooklyn.

Lake Ronkonkoma

Nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, Lake Ronkonkoma enchanted me with its shimmering waters and vibrant atmosphere. As I strolled along the scenic shoreline, I was struck by the perfect blend of natural beauty and recreational activities. The tranquil vibe invites visitors to unwind while enjoying kayaking, fishing, or simply soaking up the sun. I couldn't resist grabbing an ice cream from a nearby vendor, adding a sweet touch to my day. With its rich history and community events, Lake Ronkonkoma truly stands out as a must-visit gem on Long Island. It’s a place where adventure meets relaxation!

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Southards Pond

Nestled in the heart of Babylon, Southards Pond is a true hidden gem. As I strolled along its tranquil banks, I was captivated by the water's shimmering reflections and the gentle rustle of leaves. The vibrant wildlife, from curious ducks to soaring eagles, added a delightful touch to my visit. The serene walking trails invite leisurely exploration, making it a perfect spot for a peaceful getaway. I couldn't resist the allure of a picnic by the water—a small feast in front of such splendor! For anyone seeking nature's embrace, Southards Pond is undoubtedly a must-visit destination on Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Laurel Lake

Nestled in the charming Town of Laurel, Laurel Lake is a hidden gem that truly captivates the heart. The crystal-clear waters are perfect for a refreshing dip on warm summer days. As I strolled along the scenic trails, I was greeted by the lush greenery and the sound of birdsong, making it an ideal spot for a peaceful retreat. Families gather for picnics, while kayakers drift quietly across the surface, soaking in the serene beauty. Whether you're seeking adventure or tranquility, Laurel Lake offers a delightful escape that perfectly embodies the essence of Long Island's natural splendor.

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

Artist Lake

During my delightful visit to Artist Lake, I was captivated by its stunning beauty and tranquil atmosphere. This hidden gem, surrounded by lush greenery, offers a perfect escape from the bustle of daily life. The serene waters shimmered under the sun, inviting me for a leisurely stroll along the picturesque trails. Families gathered for picnics, while artists were inspired by the mesmerizing scenery. I couldn't resist capturing a few moments with my camera! If you're seeking a blend of relaxation and inspiration, Artist Lake is a must-visit spot on Long Island. Don't forget your sketchpad or fishing rod!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

Argyle Lake

Nestled in the charming village of Babylon, Argyle Lake is a hidden gem that captivates with its stunning scenery. As I strolled along the serene pathways, I was enchanted by the shimmering waters reflecting the vibrant colors of the sky. The lake offers a perfect backdrop for picnics, leisurely strolls, or simply soaking up the tranquility of nature. The surrounding parks provide ample space for recreational activities, ensuring a fun-filled day for visitors of all ages. If you seek a delightful escape from the hustle and bustle, Argyle Lake is a must-visit spot that beautifully embodies Long Island’s natural charm.

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Canaan Lake

Canaan Lake truly captivated me with its serene beauty! Nestled in a picturesque setting, this hidden gem offers a delightful escape from the hustle and bustle. The shimmering waters invite visitors for a relaxing afternoon of paddling or fishing, while the surrounding trails are perfect for a leisurely stroll. I was particularly enchanted by the vibrant wildlife that calls this lake home. With cozy picnic spots scattered around, it’s an ideal spot for families to unwind in nature. If you're searching for a tranquil getaway, Canaan Lake is a must-visit destination that exudes charm and serenity!

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

Swan Pond

Nestled in the heart of Long Island, Swan Pond is a hidden gem that captivated me with its serene beauty. As I strolled along the shore, the gentle ripples created a spectacular dance of light that shimmered across the water. I was charmed by the graceful swans gliding effortlessly, adding a touch of elegance to the landscape. With scenic walking paths and plenty of lush greenery, it’s the perfect spot for a peaceful escape or a delightful picnic. Overall, Swan Pond blends tranquility and charm, making it an ideal destination for nature lovers. A whimsical must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

Big Fresh Pond

Nestled in the charming town of East Hampton, Big Fresh Pond boasts a delightful blend of tranquility and natural beauty. During my visit, the serene waters sparkled under the sun, inviting me to explore its lush surroundings. As I strolled along the winding trails, I was enchanted by the melody of chirping birds and the gentle rustle of leaves. Fishing enthusiasts will find joy here, while kayakers can glide gracefully across the surface. With its picturesque backdrop, Big Fresh Pond is a hidden gem, offering a peaceful retreat for nature lovers. This lake undoubtedly deserves a spot on your “must-visit” list!

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

Hook Pond

Tucked away in East Hampton, Hook Pond is a delightful gem that captures the essence of serenity. The tranquil waters shimmer under the sun, making it perfect for a leisurely paddle or a peaceful picnic. I was enchanted by the lush surroundings and the gentle sounds of nature. The wildlife here is a treat, with ducks and swans gracefully gliding across the surface. Whether you're looking to unwind with a book or engage in some friendly fishing, this pond offers a bit of everything. Don’t miss the chance to bask in its tranquil beauty—it's simply a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.