The Absolute Best Consignment Stores in Brooklyn [Updated 2025]

With countless hours spent sifting through racks of unique treasures, I’ve uncovered some true gems tucked away in this vibrant borough. From vintage clothing that has stories to tell to home décor that adds a touch of whimsy, the thrill of the hunt is what keeps me coming back.

After reviewing 12 top locations, I’ve curated a list that reflects not just great deals, but also the character and charm of each store. You can trust my insider knowledge—I’m not just a casual shopper; I’m a dedicated explorer of Brooklyn’s consignment scene. So, whether you're a seasoned thrifter or a newbie looking for that perfect find, let me guide you to your next favorite spot!

No Relation Vintage

Highlights
Spacious store layout
Affordable prices under $30
Great condition vintage items
Convenient bargains on clothing
No refund/return policy

No Relation Vintage is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, a haven for vintage lovers and bargain hunters alike. Upon entering this spacious store, I was immediately captivated by the charming layout that allows you to peruse the racks without feeling overwhelmed. Each item is thoughtfully curated, showcasing vintage pieces that are not only stylish but also in great condition.

What truly stood out for me were the affordable prices, with many treasures ringing in at under $30! It's a thrill to discover quality clothing without breaking the bank. I spotted a stunning 90s denim jacket that made my heart skip a beat, and a pair of retro shoes that practically screamed for a night out. Talk about a wardrobe refresh!

However, be mindful of their no refund/return policy; it’s a small price to pay for such unique finds. Overall, my visit to No Relation Vintage felt like a treasure hunt where every aisle brought a new surprise. If you’re in search of distinctive pieces to add personality to your wardrobe, this store should definitely be on your consignment shopping list!

You might also want to check out the best consignment stores in Manhattan.

Harold and Maude Vintage

Highlights
Great selection of leather jackets
Unique, cozy shopping experience
Clean, well-maintained garments
Reasonably priced vintage finds
Underrated spot for vintage lovers

Harold and Maude Vintage is truly a gem tucked away in the bustling heart of Brooklyn. Upon stepping inside, I was immediately enveloped by its cozy charm, reminiscent of a beloved boutique, where every corner whispers stories of years gone by. The standout selection of leather jackets had me swooning; each piece exudes a character that modern fast fashion simply cannot replicate.

What really struck me was the immaculate condition of every garment. It's rare to see such high-quality vintage that has been so thoughtfully curated. The prices are surprisingly reasonable, especially for the unique finds that you can proudly say you own.

Despite its growing popularity, Harold and Maude maintains an air of being an underrated spot for vintage lovers. This place invites you to explore its treasures at your leisure, making for a lovely shopping experience that feels more personal than pressured.

In a world filled with fleeting trends, Harold and Maude stands as a reminder that vintage is timeless. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or a curious newcomer, I wholeheartedly recommend stopping by – you might just leave with your new favorite piece!

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

The RealReal

Highlights
Welcoming and helpful staff
Knowledgeable about trends
Comfortable shopping experience
Inconsistent in-store selection
Better options available online

The RealReal is a consignment treasure nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, and let me tell you, stepping inside feels like entering a luxurious fashion oasis. From the moment I walked through the door, the welcoming and helpful staff made me feel right at home. They are not just there to ring you up; they are genuinely knowledgeable about the latest trends and even helped me identify some stunning pieces I wouldn't have noticed on my own.

The overall shopping experience is truly comfortable; the layout is curated in such a way that each item shines beautifully under the soft lighting. However, I did notice that the in-store selection can be inconsistent—sometimes you hit the jackpot, and other times, it feels a bit sparse. If you're in search of something specific, you might find better options online, especially given their vast digital inventory.

Despite the occasional hit-or-miss selection, The RealReal embodies a chic and vibrant spirit that's worth exploring. Whether you're hunting for a designer handbag or just browsing, this consignment gem is definitely a delightful stop in Brooklyn's ever-evolving fashion scene!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Consignment Brooklyn

Stepping into Consignment Brooklyn felt like entering a treasure trove of unique finds! Their eclectic mix of vintage and contemporary pieces is nothing short of delightful. The store boasts an inviting atmosphere, where thrifting becomes an adventure. I unearthed everything from stylish clothes to quirky home décor, all meticulously curated. The staff was not only knowledgeable but also genuinely passionate about helping customers. Their prices are reasonable, making it easy to snag great deals without breaking the bank. If you’re looking to elevate your wardrobe or home, Consignment Brooklyn is an absolute must-visit for savvy shoppers!

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

m.a.e. Brooklyn

Stepping into m.a.e. Brooklyn felt like discovering a hidden treasure trove! This charming consignment shop bursts with character and an eclectic mix of styles. From vintage clothing to unique home decor, every piece tells a story. The staff radiates warmth and expertise, eager to assist without being intrusive. I loved sifting through the curated collections and stumbled upon some fabulous finds that I simply couldn't resist. The prices are quite reasonable, making it a budget-friendly haven for fashion lovers. If you’re on the hunt for something distinctive, look no further—m.a.e. Brooklyn is a delightful gem in the heart of the borough!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

BK Luxury - Buy & Sell

From the moment I stepped into BK Luxury - Buy & Sell, I was dazzled by their exquisite selection of high-end designer pieces. This gem truly caters to luxury lovers and savvy shoppers alike! The staff here are not only friendly but also incredibly knowledgeable, offering valuable insights into each item’s story. I found a stunning pair of Chanel heels that felt like they were calling my name. The prices are surprisingly reasonable for such quality! If you're on the hunt for unique treasures, definitely make a pit stop at BK Luxury—you won't regret adding this wonderful spot to your shopping list!

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Unearth Vintage

Unearth Vintage is a true treasure trove nestled in the heart of Brooklyn. Stepping inside, I was immediately captivated by the eclectic mix of vintage clothing, accessories, and quirky knick-knacks. The store exudes a charming atmosphere, with everything lovingly curated to spark joy and nostalgia. From the vibrant 70s frocks to retro statement pieces, there's something for everyone. The friendly staff is always eager to help, making the shopping experience feel personal and inviting. If you’re on the hunt for unique finds that tell a story, Unearth Vintage is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

Hybrid Vintage

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Hybrid Vintage is an absolute gem for anyone seeking unique treasures. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a delightful array of retro clothing and eclectic accessories that made my heart skip a beat. The carefully curated selection showcases everything from chic '70s dresses to funky '90s tees, all at prices that are surprisingly reasonable. The staff exudes an infectious passion for vintage fashion, offering knowledgeable recommendations without any pressure. If you're on the hunt for standout pieces, Hybrid Vintage is an enchanting stop that beautifully blends nostalgia with style.

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

Life Boutique Thrift

Stepping into Life Boutique Thrift felt like a treasure hunt in a wonderland of vintage charm! The eclectic mix of clothing and accessories showcases not just style but personality—each piece tells a story. The friendly staff are keen to help, turning every shopping trip into a delightful chat. I particularly adored their curated selection of retro dresses; it’s nearly impossible to leave without snagging something unique! If you’re on the lookout for fashionable finds that won’t break the bank and an atmosphere that feels like home, this is the spot to be. Happy thrifting!

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

28 Scott Vintage

28 Scott Vintage is a hidden gem that truly embodies the charm of Brooklyn's thrift scene! As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by a delightful mix of retro clothing and unique accessories that tell a story of their own. The curated selection was nothing short of impressive, showcasing everything from vintage dresses to funky shoes. Each item feels like a treasure waiting to be discovered. The staff is not only knowledgeable but also super friendly, making the shopping experience feel personalized. If you’re on the hunt for one-of-a-kind pieces, this cozy shop is your must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.

Beacon's Closet

Beacon's Closet is a treasure trove of stylish finds nestled in the heart of Brooklyn. As soon as I entered, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere buzzing with fashion enthusiasts. The store’s eclectic selection ranges from vintage gems to contemporary chic, making it a paradise for every style-savvy shopper. I was particularly impressed by their thoughtful curation, ensuring each piece exudes character and quality. The friendly staff is always eager to help, making the hunt for that perfect outfit all the more enjoyable. If you're seeking unique pieces that tell a story, Beacon's Closet is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best acai bowls in NYC.

Crossroads Trading

Stepping into Crossroads Trading felt like diving into a treasure trove of fashion. The curated collection features an eclectic mix of trendy and vintage pieces that cater to every style. The staff is friendly, making the shopping experience even more enjoyable. I was particularly impressed by their selection of accessories, which can elevate any outfit. Prices are reasonable considering the quality, and the store's layout is inviting and easy to navigate. If you’re on the hunt for unique finds, Crossroads is definitely a stop you won’t want to miss! Happy thrifting!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Manhattan.