NYC at Christmas' Best Bars [Updated 2025]

With twinkling lights and festive cheer in the air, there’s something magical about the bars in NYC during Christmas. After diving into the holiday spirit and reviewing 12 of the top locations, I can confidently say these spots are where the jingle bells really ring.

As someone who’s spent years sipping my way through this city, I’ve developed a keen sense for atmosphere, craft cocktails, and that elusive holiday charm that makes a bar feel like a second home during the season. Whether you’re looking for cozy nooks or dazzling decorations, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to find your perfect winter wonderland. Let’s raise a glass to unforgettable nights in the heart of the city!

Pete's Tavern

Highlights
Beautiful festive decor
Great service and vibes
Delicious comfort food
Perfect meal experience
Make a reservation recommended

Pete's Tavern truly captivates the spirit of Christmas in Manhattan. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by delightful festive decor that instantly whisked me away into a winter wonderland. The strings of twinkling lights and carefully adorned wreaths create a cozy atmosphere that makes you want to settle in and soak up the holiday cheer.

The service and vibes at Pete's were impeccable. The staff exuded warmth and enthusiasm, making you feel right at home amidst the bustling holiday season. It's no wonder this charming spot is a favorite among locals and visitors alike!

I couldn’t resist trying their delicious comfort food. Each bite was like a warm hug, perfect for combating the winter chill. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic burger or hearty pasta, Pete’s has something to satisfy every craving.

If you're considering a visit, I highly recommend making a reservation to ensure a smooth dining experience. Overall, Pete’s Tavern encapsulates everything I adore about Christmas in NYC—great food, festive cheer, and an ambiance that keeps you coming back for more. What a gem!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in NYC.

Paradise Lost

Highlights
Unique cocktails
Fun and immersive atmosphere
Friendly and attentive staff
Strong drink indicators
Perfect for dates and friends

Paradise Lost truly embodies the festive spirit during the holiday season. From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped in an atmosphere that felt both immersive and whimsical. The holiday decorations twinkled against the backdrop of lively chatter, creating a vibe perfect for intimate dates or fun gatherings with friends.

The unique cocktails served here are a delightful surprise! Each drink is a work of art, featuring innovative ingredients that not only tantalize your taste buds but also add to the festive flair of the evening. My favorite was the Christmas-themed cocktail, which sparkled with a hint of spice and sweetness, making it feel like a holiday celebration in a glass.

What truly stood out was the staff—friendly and attentive, they brought a warmth to the experience that felt genuine. They helped me navigate the menu, ensuring that I made delightful choices for my evening. If you're looking for strong drink options and a place that captures the essence of NYC during Christmas, Paradise Lost is undoubtedly a spot you don't want to miss. This bar has put a spell on me, and I can't wait to return!

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in NYC.

The Dead Rabbit

Nestled in the heart of the Financial District, The Dead Rabbit transforms into a whimsical winter wonderland during the holiday season. The warm glow of twinkling lights and lush greenery creates an inviting ambiance that feels both cozy and festive. I savored the Irish coffee, a rich blend that warmed my soul, while the joyful chatter of fellow patrons filled the air. The craft cocktails are nothing short of artful, and the delightful pub fare made my taste buds dance. In short, this bar is a must-visit for holiday cheer—where old-world charm meets modern-day magic.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Brooklyn.

Oscar Wilde

Stepping into Oscar Wilde during the holiday season feels like entering a whimsical, enchanted world. The Victorian decor beautifully adorned with twinkling lights and festive garlands creates an ambiance that is both charming and inviting. Sipping their classic Irish Coffee by the fireplace, I was enveloped in warmth and the merry spirit of the season. The bar staff exudes a delightful energy, making each guest feel like part of a festive family gathering. If you’re seeking elegance combined with a cozy vibe, Oscar Wilde is a must-visit. This bar effortlessly captures the essence of Christmas in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best breweries in NYC.

Frosty's Christmas Bar New York

Frosty's Christmas Bar New York is an absolute winter wonderland that captures the spirit of the season beautifully. From the moment I walked in, I was enveloped in a cozy ambiance filled with sparkling lights and cheerful decorations. The signature cocktails, like the Frosty Peppermint Martini, were as delightful as they were festive. Each sip transported me to a magical holiday realm. The bar staff, dressed in whimsical attire, added to the charm with their friendly service. If you’re in search of a place that combines holiday cheer with delicious drinks, look no further than this enchanting spot!

You might also want to check out the best clubs in Brooklyn.

Rolf's

Stepping into Rolf's during the Christmas season feels like wandering into a winter wonderland! Adorned with thousands of shimmering lights and whimsical decorations, it's nothing short of enchanting. The air is infused with the delightful scent of warm mulled wine and festive German fare. I savored their signature holiday cocktails, each beautifully crafted and bursting with flavor. It's a cozy space, perfect for gathering with friends, yet be prepared for a lively atmosphere—this place is a popular holiday hotspot! If you’re looking for a truly magical experience, Rolf's is a must-visit this holiday season! ✨🍹

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Brooklyn.

Sir Henry’s

Nestled among the holiday lights of NYC, Sir Henry's enchants with its cozy ambiance and festive cheer. The warm glow of twinkling lights complements a playful bar menu featuring winter-inspired cocktails, like their decadent spiced hot chocolate. As I sipped my drink, the lively tunes of classic carols transformed the space into a winter wonderland. The bartenders, masters of their craft, greeted each guest with a sparkle in their eye, adding to the welcoming spirit. If you're looking for a perfect blend of festivity and warmth, Sir Henry's is a must-visit this Christmas season!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Harlem.

Miracle on Ninth St

Stepping into Miracle on Ninth St feels like entering a whimsical holiday wonderland. The festive decor is absolutely enchanting, with twinkling lights and kitschy ornaments that put even the grumpiest Scrooge in the holiday spirit. Their signature cocktails, like the “Christmas Cookie”, are as delightful as they sound—each sip feels like a cozy hug. The atmosphere buzzes with laughter, making it perfect for holiday cheer with friends or family. Overall, this bar is a seasonal gem that beautifully captures the magic of Christmas in NYC. If you’re looking for a merry spot to celebrate, make this your festive destination!

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Brooklyn.

Holiday Cocktail Lounge

Tucked away in the heart of the West Village, Holiday Cocktail Lounge is a nostalgic gem that sparkles brighter at Christmas. Stepping inside feels like entering a cozy winter wonderland, with twinkling lights and festive decorations enveloping you in a warm embrace. I sipped their signature cocktail—the “Mistletoe Mule,” a delightful twist on the classic, bursting with holiday cheer. The ambiance is both inviting and vibrant, making it the perfect retreat from the bustling streets. If you're seeking a blend of festive cocktails and a charming atmosphere this season, this spot is a must-visit for your holiday bar crawl!

You might also want to check out the best happy hours in NYC.

Loreley Beer Garden

Stepping into Loreley Beer Garden during the Christmas season feels like a festive escape to a German winter wonderland. String lights twinkle above as a cozy, spirited atmosphere envelops you. Their seasonal mulled wine is a must-try, warm and spiced to perfection. The outdoor area, adorned with holiday decor, offers a unique charm, inviting friends to gather around a heated igloo. The cheerful staff complements the ambience, making each visit feel like a celebration. If you're seeking a touch of Bavarian cheer this holiday season, Loreley is an enchanting spot that will leave you with delightful memories and a full heart.

You might also want to check out the best hotel bars in NYC.

The Bar Room

Stepping into The Bar Room during the holiday season was like entering a festive wonderland. The ambiance sparkles with twinkling lights and the scent of mulled wine wafts through the air, creating a cozy retreat from the bustling streets. I savored their artfully crafted cocktails, perfectly complementing seasonal flavors. The attentive staff radiated holiday cheer, making every guest feel like family. I couldn't resist the delightful Christmas-themed bites, which added a charming twist to the menu. Whether you're looking for a post-shopping respite or a lively gathering spot, The Bar Room is a top choice for merriment this Christmas!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Brooklyn.

Dear Irving on Hudson Rooftop Bar

At Dear Irving on Hudson Rooftop Bar, the holiday spirit is palpable, with twinkling lights and a cozy atmosphere that feels like stepping into a winter wonderland. The stunning skyline views, paired with artful cocktails, create a truly enchanting backdrop for the season. I indulged in the seasonal sips, each crafted with care, making every drink a delightful surprise. The expertly designed interiors amplify the charm, inviting you to linger and soak in the festive vibes. If you're seeking a place to toast the holiday cheer, this rooftop gem is an unforgettable spot where magic and merriment blend seamlessly!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Long Island City.