Long Island's Best Bars [Updated 2024]

Having wandered through the vibrant streets of Long Island for numerous years, my extensive knowledge of its bar scene is unrivaled. With meticulous attention to detail, I have reviewed a staggering total of twelve establishments to bring you this definitive list.

Whether you seek a cozy neighborhood spot to gather with friends or a trendy hotspot to dance the night away, this guide has got you covered. From elegant craft cocktail lounges to laid-back dive bars, Long Island offers a diverse array of options to satisfy every palate.

So grab a drink and join me on this unforgettable journey through the best bars this island has to offer!

The Local Bar & Cafe

Highlights
Amazing conversations
Friendly bartender
Nice place to drink

As I walked into The Local Bar & Cafe, the lively atmosphere immediately caught my attention. From the moment I sat down, I found myself engaged in amazing conversations with both the patrons and the staff. It was refreshing to be in a place where people genuinely connected and shared stories over their drinks.

Speaking of drinks, the bartender at The Local Bar & Cafe was an absolute treat. Not only did they mix up some fantastic cocktails, but they also had an extensive knowledge of the bar's offerings. Their friendly and approachable demeanor made me feel right at home. Whether it was recommending a local craft beer or crafting a custom cocktail, their passion for mixology was evident.

The Local Bar & Cafe provided a nice place to drink with its comfortable seating arrangements and cozy ambiance. The warm lighting, coupled with the tasteful decor, created a space that was both inviting and relaxed. It was clear that the owners had put thought into making this spot a haven for those seeking a good drink and a great time.

I must say, I thoroughly enjoyed my visit to The Local Bar & Cafe. It had all the elements that make a bar memorable: friendly staff, great conversations, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through Long Island, make sure to stop by this gem for a memorable night out. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in NYC.

Recovery Room Bar & Grill

Highlights
Snack Attack
Sheppard's Pie
Excellent service
Chicken quesadilla
Fast drinks

When you first step into Recovery Room Bar & Grill, you'll notice the vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff. The bar is bustling, and it's clear that this is a popular spot amongst locals and visitors alike.

One of the highlights of my visit was the Snack Attack appetizer. This mouthwatering platter featured an assortment of tasty options, from cheesy mozzarella sticks to crispy onion rings. It was the perfect start to my night of indulgence.

For those looking for something more substantial, I highly recommend trying their Sheppard's Pie. It was the definition of comfort food – rich, flavorful, and oh-so-satisfying. The portion size was generous and left me feeling happily stuffed.

The service at Recovery Room was top-notch. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and always ready with a smile. They made sure to check in frequently to ensure that everything was to my liking, providing an excellent dining experience from start to finish.

Another standout dish was the Chicken Quesadilla. It was perfectly crispy on the outside and filled to the brim with tender chicken and melted cheese. The accompanying salsa and sour cream added a tangy kick that complemented the flavors perfectly.

Lastly, I must mention the fast drinks at Recovery Room. The bartenders were skilled and efficient, ensuring that my glass was never empty for long. I tried a few different cocktails throughout the night, and each one was expertly crafted and delicious.

Overall, Recovery Room Bar & Grill is a fantastic addition to the Long Island bar scene. With its inviting atmosphere, excellent service, and delectable dishes, it's a must-visit for those seeking a memorable night out.

You might also want to check out the best breweries in NYC.

The Beast Next Door

Highlights
Excellent cocktails
Seasonal cocktails
Happy hour until 7pm
Wonderfully curated charcuterie
Unique and tasty cocktails

The first thing that caught my attention at The Beast Next Door was their excellent cocktails. From classics to innovative concoctions, their drink menu was a treasure trove of delightful surprises. But what truly made them stand out were their seasonal cocktails. These carefully crafted libations were made with the freshest ingredients, capturing the flavors of each passing season.

Another highlight of The Beast Next Door was their happy hour, which lasted until 7pm. This allowed me to indulge in their delectable cocktails and delicious food without breaking the bank. Speaking of food, the wonderfully curated charcuterie board was a feast for the senses. The selection of artisanal cheeses, cured meats, and accompanying accoutrements was a perfect companion to the drinks.

But perhaps what made The Beast Next Door truly unique were their unique and tasty cocktails. Each drink was a carefully crafted masterpiece, full of interesting flavor combinations that delighted my palate. Whether it was a spicy mezcal concoction or a fruity gin-based drink, there was always something new and exciting to try.

The atmosphere of the bar was vibrant, with a mix of trendy music and a welcoming staff that added to the overall experience. The dim lighting and cozy seating made it a perfect spot to unwind after a long day or enjoy a night out with friends.

In conclusion, The Beast Next Door is a must-visit bar in Long Island for cocktail enthusiasts. Their excellent cocktails, seasonal offerings, fantastic happy hour, delicious charcuterie, and unique drink creations set them apart from the rest. So, if you're looking for a playful yet professional bar experience, make sure to check out The Beast Next Door. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best clubs in Brooklyn.

Dutch Kills

Dutch Kills, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Long Island, offers a delightful mix of playful ambiance and professionally crafted drinks. The bar's sleek decor and knowledgeable staff make it a must-visit for cocktail enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable night out. Cheers to Dutch Kills!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Brooklyn.

The Infamous

The Infamous in Long Island is a hidden gem that packs a punch! The lively atmosphere, delicious cocktails, and attentive staff make it a must-visit for any bar enthusiast. So, grab your friends, put on your dancing shoes, and prepare for a night of pure infamy at The Infamous!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Harlem.

Gantry Bar & Kitchen

Gantry Bar & Kitchen in Long Island is an absolute gem. The playful ambiance and professional service make it a top contender for the best bars in town. With their mouthwatering cocktails and delectable food options, Gantry Bar & Kitchen is a must-visit for a memorable night out.

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Brooklyn.

P J Leahy's

P J Leahy's in Long Island is an absolute gem. From the moment I stepped inside, the lively atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. The extensive drink menu had me spoiled for choice, but the bartender recommended their signature cocktail, and boy, was it delicious. The food was equally impressive, with mouthwatering appetizers that perfectly complemented my drink. Whether you're looking to unwind after a long day or enjoy a night out with friends, P J Leahy's is the place to be. Don't miss out on their cozy outdoor seating area, perfect for enjoying a drink under the stars. Trust me, this place is a winner!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Brooklyn.

McCaffrey & Burke Bar & Grill

McCaffrey & Burke Bar & Grill in Long Island is a hidden gem for bar enthusiasts. The welcoming atmosphere, delicious array of drinks, and mouthwatering bar bites make it a top contender on my best bars in Long Island list. Don't miss out on the friendly staff and amazing live music, all under one roof.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Long Island City.

Mr Beery's

Mr Beery's in Long Island is a hidden gem that effortlessly combines a cozy atmosphere with a lively crowd. With an impressive selection of craft beers and a rotating tap list that would make any beer enthusiast swoon, this place is a beer lover's paradise. The friendly staff and laid-back vibes only add to the charm of Mr Beery's. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this spot is a must-visit for anyone seeking a fun and relaxed evening out.

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Manhattan.

Changing Times Pub

Changing Times Pub in Long Island is a true hidden gem. The cozy yet vibrant atmosphere creates the perfect setting to enjoy a night out with friends. The extensive drink menu offers something for everyone, from craft beers to artisanal cocktails. The friendly staff and lively entertainment make this bar a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Brooklyn Heights.

LIC Bar

LIC Bar, oozing with charm, is an absolute gem nestled in Long Island. The trendy atmosphere, friendly staff, and eclectic drink menu make it a must-visit for bar aficionados. Sip on your favorite crafted cocktail while enjoying live music under twinkling lights. LIC Bar is a true winner!

Dominie's Hoek

Dominie's Hoek in Long Island is a hidden gem that delivers a delightful experience. The lively atmosphere is perfect for unwinding after a long day. The impressive selection of craft beers and signature cocktails will definitely leave you coming back for more. Dominie's Hoek is a must-visit for any bar enthusiast seeking a memorable night out.