The Absolute Best Anime Stores in NYC [Updated 2024]

With a total of 12 anime stores reviewed, I have scoured every corner of the city to bring you the most comprehensive list of must-visit shops. Whether you're a dedicated otaku or a curious newbie, NYC has something for everyone when it comes to anime merchandise.

From hidden gems tucked away in the bustling streets of Manhattan to trendy hotspots in Brooklyn, this guide will ensure you never miss out on the latest figurines, manga, cosplay accessories, and more. So, get ready to immerse yourself in the vibrant world of anime as we embark on this thrilling journey through the best anime stores in the Big Apple.

Project KE (Anime Club)

Highlights
Quality plushies
Kind and attentive staff
Countless amount of blind boxes
Tons of different anime figures

Walking into Project KE (Anime Club) was like stepping into a colorful realm of otaku paradise. With each step, I felt like I was embarking on an epic quest to find the most treasured anime merchandise in NYC. The store boasted an impressive selection of quality plushies, ranging from cute and cuddly creatures to beloved anime characters. I couldn't resist hugging a few of them along the way.

The staff at Project KE were not only incredibly kind, but also attentive, ready to assist me in finding exactly what I was looking for. Their passion for anime was evident in their extensive knowledge about the latest releases and hidden treasures. I couldn't help but feel welcome in their nerdy haven.

One of the highlights of this store was the countless amount of blind boxes available. It was as if I was opening a door to wonder each time I purchased one. And let's not forget the vast collection of anime figures adorning the shelves. From popular series to more obscure ones, Project KE had it all. My wallet may have shed a tear from the temptation, but it was worth every penny to bring home a piece of my favorite shows.

In conclusion, Project KE (Anime Club) is a must-visit store for any anime enthusiast in NYC. With its wide range of merchandise, from plushies to figures, and the enthusiastic and helpful staff, this store truly captures the essence of what it means to be an anime fan. So if you're searching for the best anime stores in NYC, don't forget to include Project KE on your list. Your inner otaku will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best japanese restaurant in Queens.

Toy Tokyo

Highlights
Reasonable pricing
Wide variety of toys
Basement with anime figurines
Unique Asian toys
A must-visit store

Toy Tokyo is an absolute gem for any anime fan in the city! As soon as I walked through the door, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere and rows upon rows of anime toys and merchandise.

One of the first things that stood out to me about Toy Tokyo was their reasonable pricing. Compared to other stores in the area, I was pleasantly surprised by the affordability of their products. It's refreshing to find a store that caters to anime fans without breaking the bank.

The store boasts a wide variety of toys that span across different anime series, from popular classics to the latest releases. Whether you're a fan of Naruto, Sailor Moon, or Attack on Titan, you're sure to find something that catches your eye.

The basement area is a must-visit for any anime figure collector. It's packed with shelves upon shelves of intricately detailed figurines. From beloved characters to rare finds, I was in awe of the selection they had to offer.

What sets Toy Tokyo apart from other anime stores is their collection of unique Asian toys. They have a fantastic selection of collectible toys and items that you won't find elsewhere, making this store truly stand out.

Overall, Toy Tokyo is a mecca for anime enthusiasts, offering a delightful shopping experience for fans of all ages. From reasonable pricing to a wide variety of toys and a basement filled with anime figurines, this store is a definite must-visit for anyone seeking the best anime stores NYC has to offer.

You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurant in Manhattan.

Montasy Comics NYC

Highlights
Wide selection of cards
Helpful and patient staff
Collectibles and Funky pops
Hidden gem in Manhattan

Walking through the doors of Montasy Comics NYC was like entering a vibrant oasis for anime lovers. Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, this hidden gem boasts a wide selection of cards, collectibles, and even Funky pops. As an avid collector myself, I was thrilled to see such a diverse range of merchandise on display.

What truly sets Montasy Comics NYC apart from other anime stores in the city is their helpful and patient staff. From the moment I stepped foot in the store, they greeted me with warm smiles and a genuine love for the hobby. They were more than happy to answer my questions, offer recommendations, and indulge in enthusiastic conversations about all things anime.

The store's wide selection of cards catered to both casual players and seasoned competitors. Whether I was looking for the latest booster packs or hard-to-find singles, Montasy had me covered. Their well-organized shelves made it easy to browse through various card games, including popular ones like Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh!.

But Montasy Comics NYC isn't just about cards. They also stock an impressive array of collectibles and Funky pops. From figurines of beloved characters to limited edition merchandise, there was something for every fan to add to their collection. I couldn't help but feel like a kid in a candy store, marveling at the colorful assortment of goodies.

In conclusion, Montasy Comics NYC is an absolute must-visit for any anime enthusiast. With its wide selection, helpful staff, and variety of collectibles, it ticks all the boxes of what makes an anime store truly great. So, if you find yourself in the Big Apple, make sure to pay Montasy Comics NYC a visit and indulge in your anime obsession!

You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurant in Long Island.

Anime Castle

Anime Castle in NYC is a playful paradise for anime enthusiasts! Its extensive collection of manga, figurines, and cosplay will leave you wide-eyed and giddy. With friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, this store is a mecca for all things anime. Don't miss out!

You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurants in Brooklyn.

Lunar Toy Store

With its vibrant atmosphere and vast selection of anime merchandise, Lunar Toy Store is truly a treasure trove for any anime fan. From collectible figurines to manga and cosplay accessories, this store has it all. The friendly staff and organized layout make browsing a breeze. If you're searching for that special anime item, look no further than Lunar Toy Store!

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Queens.

Anime Claw (Flushing)

Anime Claw (Flushing) in NYC is a hidden gem for anime enthusiasts like me. From plushies to manga, this store has it all. The staff was incredibly friendly and their collection was extensive. My inner otaku was in paradise. I couldn't resist leaving without a bag full of goodies. Definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurants in Queens.

Forbidden Planet

Forbidden Planet in NYC is a treasure trove for anime lovers. From shelves bursting with manga to walls adorned with action figures, this place is a dream come true. The wide selection and knowledgeable staff make it a must-visit for any anime enthusiast.

You might also want to check out the best wine stores in Manhattan.

DIGISO

Oh, DIGISO, what a delightful spot for anime enthusiasts! This trendy NYC store truly embodies the spirit of the otaku culture. The vibrant displays and vivid artwork are enough to make any fan squeal with excitement. Whether you're searching for the latest manga releases or rare collectibles, DIGISO has you covered. The friendly staff is always willing to guide you through their extensive selection, offering expert recommendations along the way. The store also plays host to engaging events, making it a hub for the anime community to connect and celebrate their shared passion. Overall, DIGISO is an anime heaven that will leave any fan in a state of pure bliss.

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Tamashii Nations Store New York

As a writer and anime enthusiast, I recently had the pleasure of visiting Tamashii Nations Store New York in NYC. This anime haven left me absolutely spellbound. From the moment I stepped foot inside, I was surrounded by vibrant displays and a palpable sense of excitement. The store's wide selection of high-quality anime merchandise was enough to make any fan weak in the knees. Whether you're searching for collectible figurines or the latest DVD releases, this place has it all. The staff, who were both knowledgeable and friendly, were more than happy to assist me in finding exactly what I was looking for. The store itself exuded a sense of professionalism and organization, making it a true paradise for any anime aficionado. If you're in NYC and can't get enough of all things anime, do yourself a favor and visit Tamashii Nations Store New York – it's truly a slice of otaku heaven.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Anime Figure Egg-Cellent 动漫手办

Anime Figure Egg-Cellent 动漫手办 in NYC was an egg-cellent discovery! This little gem is packed with a wide range of anime figures and collectibles that will leave any otaku in awe. From popular series to rare finds, this store is a treasure trove for anime enthusiasts. Don't miss out!

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

Philosopher Phlex

Philosopher Phlex in NYC is a whimsical wonderland for anime enthusiasts. Bursting with character, this store invites you to dive into a sea of manga, figurines, and all things otaku. The friendly staff, cool collectibles, and hard-to-find treasures make this shop a must-visit for any anime connoisseur.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

Midtown Comics Times Square

Midtown Comics Times Square in NYC is a paradise for anime enthusiasts like me! With its vast selection of manga, DVDs, and collectibles, I felt like a kid in an otaku candy store. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, making my shopping experience even more enjoyable. It's a must-visit spot for any anime lover in the big city.

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.