Long Island's Best Romantic Restaurants [Updated 2024]

In my quest to find the most enchanting dining spots on this idyllic island, I have personally reviewed a total of twelve establishments that exude romance and create unforgettable moments. Long Island boasts a plethora of dining options, but only a select few can truly captivate couples seeking a memorable evening.

From intimate ambiance to delectable cuisine, each of these restaurants has been handpicked to ensure a perfect setting for any romantic occasion. Whether you are celebrating a special milestone or simply looking to ignite that spark, allow me to be your trusted guide in uncovering the hidden gems that will make your heart skip a beat.

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

Highlights
Great food
Excellent service
Beautiful atmosphere
Extensive wine list
Friendly and accommodating staff

Let me start by saying that Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar has all the ingredients for a truly enchanting dining experience. From the moment I walked through the door, I was captivated by the beautiful atmosphere, which effortlessly blended elegance and warmth.

The excellent service at Prime truly stands out. The staff were friendly, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure a memorable evening. Accommodating staff made us feel like VIPs throughout the evening, making sure all of our needs were catered to.

The highlight of the evening was, of course, the food. Prime's menu offers a wide range of culinary delights, pleasing even the most discerning palates. Each dish was thoughtfully crafted and bursting with flavor. From the succulent seafood options to the perfectly cooked steaks, every bite was a celebration of taste.

To complement the outstanding cuisine, Prime boasts an extensive wine list. Whether you're a wine connoisseur or looking for the perfect pairing, their knowledgeable staff will guide you to find the perfect selection.

Overall, my experience at Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar was nothing short of enchanting. In the realm of romantic restaurants in Long Island, Prime reigns supreme. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply want to indulge in a night of culinary delights with your loved one, Prime will exceed your expectations.

You might also want to check out the best romantic restaurants in Brooklyn.

Gatsby's Landing

Highlights
Extensive cocktail menu
Beautiful pond view
Delicious Crab Cake
Tender Beef Short Rib
Friendly and accommodating staff

Upon entering Gatsby's Landing, my eyes were immediately drawn to the beautifully serene pond view. The ambiance was absolutely captivating, setting the perfect stage for a romantic evening. As I settled into my cozy seat, I quickly perused their extensive cocktail menu, feeling my excitement rise.

The moment of bliss arrived as I took my first sip of a meticulously crafted cocktail, which perfectly balanced flavors that danced on my palate. Pure magic.

Moving on to the culinary delights, the Crab Cake was simply divine. Each bite showcased an exquisite blend of flavors and textures, leaving me wanting more. The attention to detail was evident in every mouthwatering morsel.

Next up was the Beef Short Rib, which practically melted in my mouth. The tenderness was exceptional, enhanced by a rich and flavorful sauce that tantalized my taste buds. Accompanied by delightful side dishes, this dish was a true winner.

However, what truly set Gatsby's Landing apart was their staff. Their warm and friendly demeanor made me feel like a cherished guest. They were attentive and accommodating, ensuring that every moment of my dining experience was nothing less than perfect.

Overall, Gatsby's Landing is a dreamy destination for a romantic evening. With its picturesque view, punctuated by delightful cocktails, sensational dishes, and an enchanting atmosphere, this restaurant invites you to create unforgettable memories. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best pakistani restaurants in NYC.

Lakehouse

Highlights
Great food
Attentive staff
Beautiful setting
Delicious flavors
Relaxing views

Walking into Lakehouse, I was immediately struck by the beautiful setting with its stunning views of the lake. The relaxed and cozy atmosphere made me feel like I had stepped into a hidden oasis of romance.

The menu at Lakehouse offers a delightful mix of dishes, and I can confidently say that the food is nothing short of great. Each dish was expertly prepared using high-quality ingredients, resulting in a symphony of delicious flavors that left my taste buds dancing with delight. From the tender grilled salmon to the perfectly cooked filet mignon, every bite was a culinary adventure.

The staff at Lakehouse truly went above and beyond to make our dining experience unforgettable. Not only were they knowledgeable about the menu and happy to provide recommendations, but they were also incredibly attentive. From ensuring our glasses were never empty to discreetly checking in on us throughout the evening, their hospitality was second to none.

As I sat at our table, enjoying the relaxing views and savoring each bite, it became clear that Lakehouse effortlessly embodies what a romantic restaurant should be. The combination of excellent food, attentive service, and a picturesque setting makes it the perfect place to celebrate an anniversary, a special occasion, or simply to enjoy a romantic dinner with someone special.

To summarize, Lakehouse in Long Island is a hidden gem that ticked all the boxes for a romantic dining experience – great food, attentive staff, and a beautiful setting. I highly recommend giving Lakehouse a try and discovering its charms for yourself.

You might also want to check out the best german restaurant in NYC.

La Coquille

Ladies and gentlemen, grab your partners and prepare for a romantic rendezvous at La Coquille in Long Island. With its charming ambiance, delectable cuisine, and impeccable service, this gem is a must-visit for any couple seeking an extraordinary dining experience. Don't forget to indulge in the mouthwatering seafood dishes for an unforgettable evening. Trust me, this place will sweep you off your feet!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurants in NYC.

Bella Vie

Bella Vie, a charming escape in Long Island, oozes romance through its elegant decor and mouthwatering menu. The candlelit tables add a touch of intimacy, while the delectable Italian dishes transport your taste buds to a culinary haven. Perfect for a night of amour with your sweetheart!

You might also want to check out the best rooftop restaurant in NYC.

Maiella

With its enchanting ambiance, delectable Italian cuisine, and stunning waterfront views, Maiella in Long Island offers the perfect setting for a romantic evening. The attentive service and mouthwatering dishes, such as the melt-in-your-mouth filet mignon and the creamy risotto, ensure a memorable dining experience for you and your loved one. Don't forget to save room for their decadent tiramisu that will leave you craving for more. Maiella truly deserves its spot among the best romantic restaurants in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Queens.

OHK Bar & Restaurant

OHK Bar & Restaurant in Long Island is a hidden gem that truly impresses with its cozy ambiance, delectable cuisine, and attentive service. From the moment you step in, you'll be swept off your feet by the romantic lighting and intimate seating arrangement. Their menu boasts a delightful variety of dishes that cater to all tastes, from succulent seafood to mouthwatering steaks. The chefs here are true culinary wizards, crafting dishes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. The staff is remarkably attentive and knowledgeable, making sure that every need is met and every moment is special. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, OHK Bar & Restaurant is the perfect spot to ignite the flames of romance.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Brooklyn.

The Capital Grille

The Capital Grille in Long Island is a true gem when it comes to romantic dining. From the moment you step through the door, you're transported to a world of elegance and sophistication. The dimly lit dining area sets the perfect mood for a special evening with your loved one.

The ambience at The Capital Grille is top-notch. It's a blend of classic and contemporary design, creating a romantic atmosphere that is both warm and inviting. The soft lighting, cozy booths, and intimate table settings make for an unforgettable dining experience.

But it’s not just the ambience that makes this place special. The food at The Capital Grille is nothing short of exceptional. Their menu is filled with tantalizing options for every palate. From perfectly cooked steaks to fresh seafood, every dish is a masterpiece. Don't forget to save room for dessert – their crème brûlée is to die for!

What sets The Capital Grille apart from other romantic restaurants is their impeccable service. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that your evening is flawless. They are knowledgeable about the menu and can recommend the perfect wine pairing for your meal, making your dining experience even more memorable.

If you're looking for a romantic dining experience that is sure to impress, The Capital Grille in Long Island is the perfect choice. The combination of elegant ambience, exquisite cuisine, and impeccable service creates an unforgettable experience that will leave you wanting to come back for more.

You might also want to check out the best french restaurants in Brooklyn.

Seasons 52

Seasons 52 in Long Island is the perfect spot for a romantic night out. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate, with dim lighting and comfortable seating. The menu is filled with delicious options, including seasonal dishes that are fresh and flavorful. The extensive wine list adds a touch of sophistication to the evening. Overall, Seasons 52 is a must-visit for any couple looking for a special night out.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Queens.

Kyma

Kyma in Long Island is a prime spot to ignite the spark of romance. With its exquisite Mediterranean cuisine and intimate ambiance, it transports you to the shores of Greece. The fresh seafood paella and melt-in-your-mouth lamb chops will make your taste buds swoon. Let love bloom at Kyma!

You might also want to check out the best korean restaurant in Queens.

thyme restaurant

Thyme restaurant in Long Island is a whimsical and enchanting destination for romance. The luxurious décor and soft candlelight create an intimate atmosphere that sets the stage for a memorable evening. The innovative menu tantalizes the taste buds with its creative twists on classic dishes. Don't miss the divine chocolate lava cake for a truly decadent ending to your perfect evening. Thyme restaurant is the culinary cupid of Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best korean restaurant in Manhattan.

Blend on the Water

Blend on the Water in Long Island is a hidden gem that oozes romance. The stunning waterfront views, exquisite Latin cuisine, and amazing cocktails make it the perfect spot for a date night. The intimate atmosphere and attentive service add an extra touch of magic. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Manhattan.